Santa Cruz's Best Italian Restaurants [Updated 2025]

Each bite tells a story, and I’ve savored every delicious chapter in Santa Cruz’s vibrant Italian dining scene. After countless meals and late-night pasta cravings, I’ve rounded up my top twelve spots that truly capture the essence of Italian cuisine.

You can trust my taste buds—I've explored everything from cozy family-run gems to trendy eateries that put a modern twist on classic dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for a comforting plate of carbonara or a fresh, zesty pizza, I’m here to guide you through the flavors that make Santa Cruz a hidden treasure for Italian food lovers. Let's dive into this culinary adventure together!

Tramonti

Highlights
Intimate dining experience
Amazing lasagna
Tartufo mushroom pizza
Good portion size
Soggy pizza crust

Tramonti Review

At Tramonti, stepping into the cozy ambiance felt like a warm embrace from Italy itself. The intimate dining experience is truly one of the restaurant's highlights, making it an ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a heartfelt catch-up with friends. As I perused the menu, I was drawn to their amazing lasagna—a dish that definitely lived up to the praise. Loaded with rich layers of cheese and hearty meat, each bite was a little piece of heaven.

Another standout was the tartufo mushroom pizza, a delightful medley that had me savoring every mouthful. The flavor combination was impeccable, though I did find the crust to be somewhat soggy, which detracted slightly from the overall experience. However, the generous portion sizes more than made up for it; I left with a satisfied stomach and a smile on my face.

What truly sets Tramonti apart is their dedication to creating a memorable experience for each guest. Whether you're a Santa Cruz local or just passing through, this charming Italian restaurant is worth a visit, if only to indulge in their delectable dishes. I'll definitely be returning for another taste of their culinary magic!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurant in Mountain View.

Sugo Italian Pasta Bar

Highlights
Family-friendly atmosphere
Quick and attentive service
Delicious carbonara and ragu
Amazing bread and carpaccio
Worth visiting multiple times

Sugo Italian Pasta Bar in Santa Cruz is an absolute gem for anyone craving authentic Italian cuisine. From the moment I stepped inside, the family-friendly atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug. The decor echoes a rustic charm, making it the perfect setting for a cozy dinner or a cheerful gathering with loved ones.

What truly delighted me was the attentive service; the staff seemed genuinely dedicated to making every guest feel special. As I perused the menu, I was drawn in by their enticing options, ultimately deciding on the carbonara and a classic ragu. Each dish was a revelation, bringing forth layers of flavor that transported me straight to Italy. The carbonara was creamy and indulgent, while the ragu boasted a depth of taste that lingered beautifully.

Don’t even get me started on the homemade bread! The fresh, warm bread paired perfectly with their divine carpaccio, setting the tone for an unforgettable meal. Trust me, after one visit, you’ll find yourself returning to Sugo time and again, hungry for more of their exquisite offerings. If you’re in Santa Cruz, this spot is not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurants in Santa Clara.

Ivéta Downtown

Highlights
Friendly and attentive staff
Roman-style sausage pizza
Homemade desserts
Comfy and inviting atmosphere
Great brunch options

Ivéta Downtown is a delightful gem that captivates you the moment you step inside. The ambiance is as inviting as a warm hug on a chilly day, with a cozy atmosphere perfect for enjoying great food. The friendly and attentive staff made me feel right at home, ensuring that my experience was nothing short of exceptional.

As I browsed the menu, I couldn't resist trying the Roman-style sausage pizza. Oh, what a masterpiece! The crust was perfectly crispy, with the ideal blend of toppings that made each bite a joyful celebration of flavors. It was the kind of pizza that dances on your palate and leaves you craving just one more slice.

Besides the savory delights, Ivéta also offers homemade desserts that are a must-try. I indulged in a rich tiramisu that felt like a sweet embrace, rounding off the meal with blissful satisfaction.

With an array of delectable brunch options alongside their dinner offerings, Ivéta Downtown truly caters to all your culinary desires. If you’re in Santa Cruz, don’t miss out on this Italian haven—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in San Jose.

The Pastaria & Market

Highlights
Delicious basil pasta
Unique apple Gorgonzola pizza
Outstanding gnocchi experience
Mole cola is a must-try

Visiting The Pastaria & Market was like stepping into an Italian kitchen brimming with warmth and flavor! One dish that truly stole my heart was their delicious basil pasta. It was wonderfully al dente, tossed in a fragrant basil sauce that sang of the sun-drenched Italian countryside. I couldn't resist trying their unique apple Gorgonzola pizza as well. Who knew a sweet and savory blend could work so harmoniously on a crust?

Now, let's talk gnocchi—oh, the outstanding gnocchi experience! Each bite was a pillow of delight, perfectly melting in my mouth and complemented by a rich sauce that was a little slice of heaven. And let’s not overlook their fabulous drink selection. Don’t skip the mole cola; this innovative beverage is a must-try that adds an adventurous twist to the meal.

The ambiance was lively yet cosy, making it an ideal spot for both family gatherings and romantic dinners. The staff was friendly and welcoming, enhancing my overall experience. With such incredible dishes and a charming setting, The Pastaria & Market has certainly earned its spot among the top Italian restaurants in Santa Cruz!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Sunnyvale.

Lillian's Italian Kitchen

Lillian's Italian Kitchen is a delightful gem nestled in Santa Cruz. From the moment I walked in, the warm ambiance embraced me like a hug from a nonna. The handmade pasta is a revelation; each bite melts in your mouth, reminiscent of Italy's charming trattorias. Their signature dish, the Pesto Gnocchi, is a heavenly dance of flavors—rich yet vibrant. The attentive staff adds to the charm, making every visit feel special. If you're craving authentic Italian comfort food, Lillian's is an absolute must-try. Delectable, welcoming, and oh-so-satisfying, this restaurant captures the heart of Italy in every plate.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in San Jose.

Lago di Como

Nestled by the picturesque harbor, Lago di Como is a delightful escape into Italian cuisine. The ambiance strikes a charming balance between quaint and vibrant, making it perfect for both romantic evenings and cheerful gatherings. I savored the homemade gnocchi, which melted in my mouth, paired with a rich basil pesto that danced on my taste buds. The staff exuded warmth, enhancing the dining experience. Don't miss their tiramisu—a sweet finale that crowns the meal! If you're craving authentic flavors and a cozy atmosphere, Lago di Como is a must-visit gem in Santa Cruz.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Santa Cruz.

Bedda Mia

Nestled in the heart of Santa Cruz, Bedda Mia is a delightful escape into the flavors of Italy. From the moment I stepped inside, the charming decor set a cozy tone that felt like a home away from home. I savored their handmade pasta, which was a dream—perfectly al dente and doused in a rich, flavorful sauce. The staff exuded warmth and enthusiasm, making the dining experience even sweeter. I left with a satisfied palate and a heart full of joy. If you're seeking authentic Italian vibes, Bedda Mia is a treasure not to be missed!

You might also want to check out the best vegan restaurants in San Jose.

La Posta

La Posta, a hidden gem in Santa Cruz, truly captures the essence of Italian dining. With its charming ambiance and rustic decor, the moment you step inside, you're transported to Italy. The homemade pasta, especially the pappardelle, melts in your mouth, and the rich, flavorful sauces are a delightful touch. To top it off, the extensive wine list offers something for every palate. The staff is both knowledgeable and friendly, adding to the welcoming vibe. If you're looking for a taste of Italy without leaving town, La Posta is an absolute must-visit! Buon appetito!

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurant in Santa Clara.

Gabriella Café

Nestled among the vibrant streets of Santa Cruz, Gabriella Café is a delightful gem that truly shines. From the moment I stepped in, the inviting ambiance wrapped around me like a warm hug. The fresh, homemade pasta deserves a standing ovation; it was delectably al dente and paired beautifully with rich sauces. I couldn't resist trying their signature dish—each bite was a flavorful dance on my palate! The staff was friendly and attentive, adding a personal touch to my meal. If you're in search of authentic Italian cuisine with a cozy atmosphere, Gabriella Café is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best korean restaurant in Santa Clara.

Avanti Restaurant

Stepping into Avanti Restaurant felt like being whisked away to a charming trattoria in Italy! The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it the perfect spot for a cozy dinner. I savored their signature pasta primavera, bursting with fresh, vibrant vegetables and perfectly al dente noodles. The rich tomato sauce had just the right amount of zest. Don’t skip the tiramisu for dessert; it’s decadently delightful! The attentive staff adds to the experience, making you feel right at home. If you're searching for authentic flavors in Santa Cruz, Avanti should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurant in Fremont.

Oblò Cocktails & Kitchen

I had the pleasure of dining at Oblò Cocktails & Kitchen in Santa Cruz, where the blend of rustic charm and culinary creativity stole my heart! Their house-made pasta was a triumph, showcasing fresh ingredients and masterful technique. I savored every bite of the truffle fettuccine, which was decadently rich yet balanced. The lively atmosphere is perfect for both casual evenings and special occasions. Don't miss their inventive cocktails, which pair beautifully with the menu. Overall, Oblò offers a delightful rendezvous with Italian cuisine that keeps you coming back for more—an absolute gem in the heart of Santa Cruz!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Palo Alto.

Upper Crust Pizza & Pasta

Tucked away in the heart of Santa Cruz, Upper Crust Pizza & Pasta is a delightful gem that truly elevates comfort food. From the moment I stepped in, the warm, inviting atmosphere wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. The hand-tossed pizzas are a masterpiece, boasting a crispy crust and topped with fresh ingredients that burst with flavor. Their pasta dishes, especially the creamy fettuccine alfredo, are rich and satisfying. The staff are friendly and attentive, adding to the overall charm. If you’re on the hunt for a slice of Italian bliss, Upper Crust is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Santa Cruz.